Well here is one mediocre review I did not see happening. I swore that I was going to love this book and that it was going to be the most epic thing I have ever read and as it turns out I was just not that into it.
Although I gave this book an average rating and I found the actual plot to somewhat average, this is by no means an average book. Taylor Jenkins Reid is an astonishing writter and she has this uncanny ability to write realistic characters, that come through unique situations. Just enough realism mixed with fiction. This story is different in every sense of the word, and most people would say that they have never heard a story like this before. Well, I am not most people. My lack of enthusiasm for this book actually takes place a long time ago and with another book. If you followed me when I used to blog on alliereads, then you may remember about 2yrs ago I read a very underrated christian fiction book called, Beneath a Southern Sky by Deborah Rainy here’s the goodreads if you want to check that out. Basically the book is about a married ouple who are South American missionaries, the husband is a doctor and is called away to a neighboring village to assist with a flu epidemic. However, while there the village comes under attack and is burned to the ground, and there are no assumed survivors. The main character is then sent home (I am so sorry, I do not remember her name, and I do not feel like digging out the book) to Kentucky and there she has to begin to start her life over. She then discovers she is pregnant with her first child, by her dead husband. Then shortly after she falls in love and marries a very amazing man, who takes care of her and fathers her child. Then out of nowhere she recieves a call saying that her first husband is actually alive and is coming home.. ( do you see the resemeblences?) And from there we examine the prospects of both relationships. It was a very emotional and thought provoking read. The whole time I was reading it I kept thinking about how I would handle these situations. I’m sorry I’ve already reviewed this book and I’m not here to review it again. But, I said all this to say, that this storyline is not new to me, I have seen it done before and frankly done much better. In Beneath a Southern Sky, story went more in depth about the previous couples relationship, more in depth with her new relationship and I felt like the grieving process was even handled with much more emotion. The stories are eerily similar, even the endings and while I did enjoy them both, I felt so much more connected to the previous story. Now I know it’s unfair for me to try and compare the two, and though it seems like that’s what I was doing. I promise I wasn’t. I just knew the great potential that this book had bc of the author and I already knew that this plot could be beautifully done.
By all acounts this book was heartbreaking and gut wrenching, it was one of those books that I wished had made me cry. (I’m not a crier, so that is very rare). I really enjoy Reid’s writting style, the best word I can think of to describe it would be monotone, not in a bad way. Whenever I sit down to read one of her books, I know that no matter how emotionally charged the book is, it’s still going to have an overall chill and peaceful feel to it. I was easily able to get into the story and able to get a feel for the characters, yet this book just left me feeling so unsatisfied at the end. I think I needed to see for myself the love that Jesse and Emma had. I understand that they had this wild, adventerous lifestyle and that they followed their dreams and seen the world together. I needed more of that, I needed to see that and feel that attraction that she had towards him, so that I could better understand her grief and hesitations. I wanted to feel her turmoil with her, but I could not bc all I got to see was how they met in highschool and a few pages about what they had been doing since. I just a hard time connecting. I did understand her relationship with Sam a lot more, only bc I had gotten to see it unfold, however I felt it was just there to create conflict and more of a plot device than a real relationship. I know this review makes me sound as if I really disliked this book and that most certainly isn’t true. I think I had mostly set myself up for disappointent by relying too much on the hype surrounding it. Once I got past my issues with the romances, I was able to focus on what this story is truly about, and that is self discovery. Emma transformed so much from the girl eager to leave her hometown and her parents expectations to ultimately discovering that what she was always looking for was always in her own backyard. The parts that made me wish I could cry were not the romantic parts, or even the grief. They were the times when Emma realized who she was and embraced it. Learning and growing through the unexpected and being able to come out on the otherside more sure of yourself than you ever were: that’s a story worth reading.
Taylor Jenkins Reid is an amazing writter, I have so far read 3 of her books and I own all of them. While this one was not my favorite or least favorite I am wanting to re-read it, now that I know the outcome and can really focus in on anything I missed..